| 1 | Mitchell Whitmore (Senior) | USA | 36.03 | | - |
| 2 | Matthew Rittenhouse (Neo) | USA | 36.25 | SB | +0.220 |
| 3 | Kimani Griffin (Senior) | USA | 36.37 | | +0.340 |
| 4 | Brett Perry (Neo) | USA | 37.05 | | +1.020 |
| 5 | Alexander Mark (Senior) | USA | 37.06 | | +1.030 |
| 6 | KC Boutiette (Senior) | USA | 37.16 | SB | +1.130 |
| 7 | Steven Hartman (Neo) | USA | 37.55 | | +1.520 |
| 8 | Stephen Paul Kilari (Neo) | IND | 39.75 | | +3.720 |
| 9 | John Sullivan (Neo) | USA | 40.18 | | +4.150 |
| 10 | Alex Zamojski (A2) | USA | 40.63 | | +4.600 |
| 11 | Robert Goodwin (Neo) | USA | 40.88 | | +4.850 |
| 12 | Jacob Roberts (B2) | USA | 42.35 | | +6.320 |
| 13 | Ian Quinn (Neo) | USA | 42.38 | | +6.350 |
| 14 | Casey Dawson (C1) | USA | 43.79 | | +7.760 |
| 15 | Roy Hoffman (M30) | USA | 46.43 | | +10.400 |
| 16 | William Valentine (C1) | USA | 46.56 | | +10.530 |
| 17 | Troa Vimahi (E2) | USA | 51.56 | | +15.530 |
| 18 | Dylan Woodbury (E1) | USA | 53.79 | | +17.760 |
| DNS | Clay James Cholewinski (Senior) | USA | DNS | | - |